12 Best Vanilla Extract for Coffee 2024 – Full & Tasty Flavor

If you’re a coffee-lover and you like experimenting with different coffee creamer flavors, you probably already tried adding vanilla extract to it and you know it tastes like heaven. If you haven’t, now is the perfect time to try it out and give your tastebuds what they’ll definitely end up craving afterward.

But, finding the best vanilla extract for coffee isn’t always the easiest task since there are a million options out there. It’s not difficult to get confused and not know which one to get. That is why we swoop in with a ready-made list of the best vanilla extracts for coffee out there! You don’t have to waste time at all—all you need to do is look at our list and our buying guide to inform yourself on how to get the perfect product in no time!

Top Picks Vanilla Extract for Coffee

1. Watkins Vanilla Extract – Strong

Watkins Vanilla Extract

The first one on our list of the best vanilla extracts for coffee is Watkins vanilla extract, and it’s one of the most popular choices out there. People enjoy this product because of its pure flavor which is made from all-natural flavors. Watkins vanilla extract, although perfect for coffee, is also excellent for cooking and preparing desserts and other drinks.

Here’s what makes Watkins vanilla extract an amazing choice:

  • It is made with pure vanilla extract and all naturally derived ingredients
  • Concentrated, bake, and freeze-proof, this blend is ideal for baking and cooking a variety of foods and desserts as well
  • With no artificial colors or flavors, you’ll find this product safe to use at any time
  • Watkins vanilla extract is Gluten-Free, Corn Syrup Free, and Kosher
  • Natural ingredients
  • Strong
  • No artificial color or flavors
  • Not pure vanilla extract


2. Native Vanilla Vanilla Extract – Vegan

Native Vanilla Vanilla Extract

The next one on our list is a vanilla extract made by the brand called Native Vanilla. This product is amazing since it’s 100% pure vanilla extract with a strong natural flavor, so not only can you use it to make your perfect cup of morning coffee, but also to prepare various dishes, desserts, and foods you’re craving. What separates this vanilla extract from others on the market is the fact that it has a sweet fragrance and a very potent flavor with strongly aromatic, warm, and floral notes.

The extract is made from real vanilla beans, and no additives, colorants, or fake flavors were added to it. It also contains zero sugars and is Kosher and Vegan certified. You can use it as an ingredient for cooking and baking numerous desserts, such as cakes, cookies, and ice cream, but also use it to flavor beverages, such as coffee and cocktails.

  • Natural flavor
  • No sugars
  • Vegan
  • Not strong

3. Pyure Vanilla Extract – Sugar-free

Pyure Vanilla Extract

We’ll continue with Pyure vanilla extract which is plant-based and has zero calories and sugar. Pyure vanilla extract can be used as a liquid sugar substitute since it is a sugar-free sweetener that provides you with the sweetness of regular sugar without adding any extra calories or carbs. You can use it to sweeten any beverage you want, including keto coffee, iced tea, and yogurt.

This extract is organic, plant-based, natural, and made of the highest quality ingredients. It is USDA Organic Certified and Non-GMO Project Verified, and it has zero calories, sugar, carbs, and glycemic index. With Pyure vanilla extract, you can rest assured you’ll get the healthiest version of your beverage. So, if you’re on a diet, you don’t have to worry about a thing! The extract is perfect for the keto diet, diabetic, gluten-free, paleo, vegan, and plant-based. What more could we wish for?

  • Sugar-free
  • Organic
  • Plant-based and natural
  • Might be too sweet


4. Javy Coffee Vanilla Extract – Gluten-free

Javy Coffee Vanilla Extract

Javy Coffee vanilla extract works a bit differently—pour 1-2 teaspoons of Javy cold brew concentrate into water or milk and your perfect cup of coffee will be ready to go in mere seconds. You will need no coffee grounds, no mess, no preparation, and no brewing equipment, which makes it super easy and convenient to make your beverage quickly. Enjoying your cold brew whenever and wherever you want has never been easier!

You don’t have to go out to get a fresh cup of coffee when you have Javy liquid coffee concentrate in your workplace or at home. You can have your so-needed coffee in your hands in a matter of minutes without the need for any brewing equipment and without making any mess.

If you’re someone who wants to experiment with different coffee flavors or find new ones, Javy coffee extracts will be the cherry on top of your regular cold brew coffee. No matter if you want to make hot or iced coffee, you can enjoy this coffee extract taste in every sip you take.

Javy coffee concentrates are made of ultra-pure water, fresh coffee beans, and vanilla extract, and these are all high-quality ingredients sourced from reliable farmers. The products also don’t consist of any additives, sugars, or harmful chemicals. Since they are non-GMO, sugar-free, and gluten-free products, they are an ideal and safe gift for all the coffee lovers out there. Who can go wrong with a tasty and delicious vanilla-flavored coffee gift?

  • High-quality ingredients
  • No harmful chemicals
  • Gluten-free
  • Bad packaging


5. Monin Vanilla Extract – Organic

Monin Vanilla Extract

Monin is one of the most popular brands of coffee extracts worldwide. People enjoy this product for its organic, vegan, and gluten-free ingredients that taste like a dream! Here’s why Monin vanilla extract is an amazing choice:

  • Once you add Monin vanilla extract to your beverages, you’ll be able to taste the rich vanilla bean extract and not worry about a thing knowing that it’s made with organically grown pure cane sugar and the best natural flavors out there
  • This extract adds rich and smooth flavor to your coffee, but also to other beverages, such as smoothies, shakes, cocktails, or even whipped cream
  • If you’re worried about the ingredients, don’t be! Monin vanilla extract is allergen-free, dairy-free, gluten-free, halal, and kosher. It’s made with no artificial colors, no artificial flavors, no artificial ingredients, no artificial preservatives, no artificial sweeteners, and it is also non-GMO, organic, and clean label

What is also incredible about this brand is that it is set on helping the world be a better and healthier place by sending waste extract to feed bees ever since 2008. If you’re someone who cares about the environment, you’ll be happy to know that Monin’s 100% recyclable boxes are comprised of 30% recycled content and printed with biodegradable ink that contains zero pollutants.

  • Organic
  • Gluten-free
  • Allergen-free
  • Doesn’t last long


6. Nielsen-Massey Vanilla Extract – Allergen-free & Gluten-free

Nielsen-Massey Vanilla Extract

We’ll conclude our list of the best vanilla extracts for coffee with the gluten-free sweet and creamy Nielsen-Massey vanilla extract. Nielse-Massey vanilla extract is made of water, alcohol (35%), sugar, and vanilla bean extractives. This product is the perfect all-purpose vanilla extract for your coffee, but also for other beverages as well as desserts. If you’re craving vanilla chocolate chip cookies, you can use this extract to make a perfect batch of those!

They will certainly be sweet, creamy, and mellow, with delicious velvety after-tones. Since the product is all-natural, allergen-free, non-GMO, kosher, and gluten-free, you won’t have to worry about a thing before adding it to your food or drinks.

  • Allergen-free
  • Kosher
  • Gluten-free
  • Watery taste


Buying Guide

Best Vanilla Extract for Coffee Buying Guide

If you want to avoid purchasing a product that won’t fit your needs entirely, you should make sure you know how to identify the one that will work like a charm. Although that may sound like it is easier said than done, we’re here to show you how you can pinpoint the perfect vanilla extract for coffee in actual minutes.

The secret to this is that you need to do some research before purchasing your product. This should not take much of your time, but figuring out what factors to consider when checking product descriptions can.

That is why provide you with a summarized list of things you should pay attention to when choosing your vanilla extract. That way, you don’t have to waste any more of your time than you have to and you can have the product in your hands in the blink of an eye. Here’s what you should take into consideration:

1. Quality

The quality of the product you buy is the most important factor to consider, and for a good reason. It’s no secret that high-quality products are often more expensive than lower-quality ones, but they are also usually much better and safer to use/consume. The same rules apply when it comes to the quality of the vanilla extract for your coffee.

Since you will be consuming the drink, you have to be 100% certain that the liquid is completely safe to consume and made of the highest-quality ingredients. You can find such info by checking product descriptions of the ones you’re looking to purchase.

2. Ingredients

Buying Guide

As we have already mentioned, the ingredients of the vanilla extract you want to purchase need to be of the highest quality if you want to avoid any inconveniences or mishaps. This info can be found by looking through customer reviews and product descriptions.

What you want to look for are the ingredients that are organic and natural. If you suffer from allergies, you are already aware that double-checking this info is of utmost importance. You want to look for products that are allergen-free, dairy-free, gluten-free, halal, and kosher. That way, you won’t have to worry about whether it is safe to consume or not and you can save yourself from any potential hassle.

3. Label

The last thing you should consider before you purchase a product is the label on it. The reason why this is important is that only the products labeled pure vanilla extract are in fact extracts. If you find one that is labeled “flavor,” it likely can’t contain alcohol.

The vanilla flavor is also less strong than vanilla extract, so if you want your beverage or dessert to have that intense vanilla aftertaste we know and love, you should go with products labeled as vanilla extract.


FAQ Best Vanilla Extract for Coffee

1. Do I Need To Refrigerate My Vanilla Extract After Opening It?

If you aren’t used to using vanilla extract in your cooking, you’re probably not sure about what the best way to keep it is. The truth is, the vanilla extract shouldn’t be kept in a refrigerator. You can use this product for a long period of time, especially if it’s high-quality, but you should always keep it in a dark and cool place, away from any heat. Don’t freeze it or refrigerate it even after opening it.

2. What Can I Use Vanilla Extract For?

There is no shortage of things you can use vanilla extract for. Although putting it in your coffee is one of the best ways to improve the tastiness of your drink, there are a lot more uses for this product. They include baking desserts, such as cookies, cake, custards, and a variety of other delicious treats to satisfy your sweet tooth.

You can also use vanilla extract for roasted fruit, plain yogurt, almond butter, smoothies, almond flour pancakes, banana soft serve, coffee or lattes, coconut whipped cream, and more.

3. What Is the Best Vanilla Extract Out There?

You can find a ton of different brands that provide high-quality vanilla extract for coffee, including Monin, Watkins, and more. No matter what brand you end up choosing, you should always make sure that the product you’re purchasing is made of high-quality ingredients to avoid running into any issues or having to return it later on.

There’s no need to go through such hassles when you can avoid it altogether by reading our buying guide and choosing the best vanilla extract on the market like a pro.


Buying any product, especially the ones you’ll consume with food or drinks, is not always the easiest task. You have to be careful with what you choose and make sure it is safe to use.

Since purchasing the best vanilla extract for coffee can also prove challenging, make sure you study our buying guide before choosing the product you want. That way, you will be able to identify the best one in a matter of minutes and like a pro!